Accountant Michelle Arbitrio

Michelle M. Arbitrio

Based on reviews
Licensed for 16 years, ID: 00000
10601, New York [NY], White Plains
Practice areas
Accountant (Auditor)

10601, New York, NY, White Plains

9 a.m. - 4 p.m.

(914) 872-7788

About Michelle


Michelle litigates, tries and appeals complex professional, commercial, coverage, life insurance, ERISA and employment disputes in state and federal courts and defends securities arbitrations before the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA).

She takes particular pride in her skillful defense of those professionals for whom the need to manage potential exposure has never been greater, including insurance agents, real estate agents and mortgage brokers. Intimately familiar with the business of law, the business of insurance and the delicate calculus of balancing one against the other, Michelle commits herself to addressing the needs of in-house counsel, underwriters, brokers and other insurance professionals – many of whom consider her as much colleague as counsel.

A practicing attorney for 14 years, Michelle’s instinctive leadership abilities are already very much in evidence. She trains and manages a talented team of associates and paralegals and is regularly consulted by fellow partners who appreciate her sound perspectives and ideas. In fact, her ability to work cross-practice frequently spawns innovative and cost effective resolutions of her clients’ most challenging legal issues. While other adjectives commonly ascribed to Michelle include “honorable,” “approachable” and “tenacious,” perhaps she’s proudest of being considered a “lawyer’s lawyer” who garners the enduring respect of colleagues and clients alike.

Areas of Focus

Professional Liability
Michelle handles professional liability matters involving securities brokers and broker-dealers, insurance agents, real estate agents, government officials and employees, staffing agents and numerous other types of professionals in errors and omissions claims where their professional conduct is at issue.

Securities & Financial Services Litigation
Michelle focuses her securities litigation practice on the representation of broker-dealers, registered representatives and other industry professionals in claims involving violations of state and federal securities laws, and violations of FINRA rules and regulations. In addition, Michelle counsels firms and financial professionals regarding compliance issues and regulatory enforcement matters, which can cause extensive harm to a client's reputation or business prospects. She engages in proactive activities with regulators at the earliest stages of the process.

Life, Health, Disability and ERISA 
Regarding ERISA and non-ERISA life, health and disability insurance claims, Michelle regularly consults with and represents insurers on a wide range of long-term and short-term disability matters; complex life insurance issues, including fraud investigations, stranger-owned and investor-owned (STOLI/IOLI) cases, material misrepresentation cases and suicide cases; and rescission, declaratory judgment and interpleader actions. Michelle also has experience with ERISA-related class actions.

Employment Litigation
Michelle represents employers in a wide variety of discrimination cases and sexual harassment cases. In addition, she has litigated matters involving non-competition agreements and corporate control disputes and regularly advises clients on these issues. As dictated by client needs and best practices, Michelle works with other functional areas within the firm, including cyber risk, privacy rights, employment law, management liability, government affairs, unfair competition, class actions and commercial/transactional services.


  • Bar
    • New York, Connecticut
  • Courts
    • U.S. District Court, Eastern, Northern and Southern Districts of New York
      U.S. District Court, District of Connecticut
      U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit

Memberships & Affiliations

Breadwinners Foundation, board of directors
New York State Bar Association
DRI: The Voice of the Defense Bar
Professional Liability Underwriting Society (PLUS)
Claims and Litigation Management Alliance (CLM)

Awards & Distinctions

Rising Star – Westchester’s 40 Under 40


  • Pace University School of Law, J.D., 2002, 

    cum laudePace International Law Review, articles editor 

  • Providence College, B.A., 1999, 

    cum laude, History Honor Society, Political Science Honor Society

Reviews (0)
Only authorized users can review the CPA. Please Sign In or Sign Up.
It take only one minute of your time!